Crumbl Cookie is a place that people either love or hate. For the ones who love it, last week’s flavors were truly delicious. Coming off of that, there were high expectations for this week’s flavors. To be completely honest, these expectations weren’t met, but the flavors were not entirely disappointing.
The flavors for the week of September 23-28th were milk chocolate chip, confetti cake, birthday cake w/ Oreo, peanut butter w/ Snickers, caramel shortbread w/ Twix, and a pink sugar cookie.
The only flavors that I tried were the confetti cake, birthday cake, caramel shortbread, and the pink sugar cookie. Out of those four, the birthday cake with Oreo was my favorite. It had a great chocolate cookie taste with good vanilla frosting on top. I would probably rate that one a 9/10.
Second, I liked the confetti cake a lot as well. It wasn’t super special because it tasted like a normal cake, but I would still give it an 8.5/10.
The caramel shortbread was pretty interesting. I liked how it almost had caramel inside the cookie, it made the texture very nice, but it wasn’t super amazing. It had good sweetness and consistency, but I’d rate it a 7.5/10.
Lastly, the most disappointing cookie (not to my surprise) was the pink sugar cookie. I thought it was plain boring and had a sub-par taste. I would rate it a simple 5/10.
Senior Luna Han tried the cookies and had to say this about the peanut butter cookie: “I wasn’t a huge fan of this cookie because it was way too sweet. But, it kind of tasted like a Reese’s Pieces. But me personally I’m not a huge peanut butter fan.”
The Crumbl flavors of this week were certainly not a letdown, but they also did not meet the same hype as the ones of the week before. If you are a fan of savory and cake-like desserts, I would most definitely recommend you go out to Crumbl and try these flavors before they are gone on Monday, the 30th.
vasili • Oct 15, 2024 at 9:58 PM
I agree with the fact that these flavors were delicious because they really were. The confetti cake and the oreo birthday cake were very good. I would have rated them very high if I were to rate them. I am not a big fan of pink sugar, but I also enjoyed the Twix cookie. I did not get a chance to try the Snickers cookie.
christy • Oct 14, 2024 at 6:43 PM
I personally think that the crumbl cookies of that week were really good but the birthday cake with oreo was a bit too sweet and it would be nice if crumbl made cookies allergy friendly.
Dala • Oct 14, 2024 at 5:36 PM
I agree with all the ratings of that week’s cookie. When I tried it that week, I was disappointed with pink sugar because it had no flavor and was overhyped.
Spencer • Oct 13, 2024 at 7:21 PM
I really enjoyed this week’s flavors especially the confetti cake.
Jaden • Oct 13, 2024 at 4:31 PM
I remember when I tried these cookies, and they were very good. My favorite is the Oreo birthday cake too. This article was very informative.
Brady O'Loughlin • Oct 13, 2024 at 12:37 AM
I had the chance to try these cookies when they came out. I agree with the rating of 8.5/10 for the confetti cake. It was delicious, but a little too sweet. It was definitely one of my favorites, but my favorite was the Twix one. I thought the cookie itself was very good and the addition of the caramel, chocolate, and Twix pieces on top completed the cookie. I would have rated that one a 9.2/10.
Grayson • Oct 11, 2024 at 11:33 AM
The birthday cake w/ Oreo seems pretty good, since I like Oreos, and birthday cake is a solid flavor for a cookie. Maybe I’ll go and try it out. Thank you Luna for reviewing the peanut butter cookie.
lexi • Oct 11, 2024 at 9:51 AM
I love Crumbl! Most of the time, Crumbl has a flavor I would like to try. No flavor has ever disappointed me, and I’m always willing to return for the following week’s line-up.